- Title: The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing
- Author: Mark McGurl
- ISBN: 9780674033191
- Page: 448
- Format: Hardcover
In The Program Era, Mark McGurl offers a fundamental reinterpretation of postwar American fiction, asserting that it can be properly understood only in relation to the rise of mass higher education and the creative writing program McGurl asks both how the patronage of the university has reorganized American literature and even important how the increasing intimacyIn The Program Era, Mark McGurl offers a fundamental reinterpretation of postwar American fiction, asserting that it can be properly understood only in relation to the rise of mass higher education and the creative writing program McGurl asks both how the patronage of the university has reorganized American literature and even important how the increasing intimacy of writing and schooling can be brought to bear on a reading of this literature.McGurl argues that far from occasioning a decline in the quality or interest of American writing, the rise of the creative writing program has instead generated a complex and evolving constellation of aesthetic problems that have been explored with energy and at times brilliance by authors ranging from Flannery O Connor to Vladimir Nabokov, Philip Roth, Raymond Carver, Joyce Carol Oates, and Toni Morrison.Through transformative readings of these and many other writers, The Program Era becomes a meditation on systematic creativity an idea that until recently would have seemed a contradiction in terms, but which in our time has become central to cultural production both within and beyond the university.An engaging and stylishly written examination of an era we thought we knew, The Program Era will be at the center of debates about postwar literature and culture for years to come.
Recent Comments "The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing"
McGurl is firing too many pistons at once, obscuring this otherwise interesting part-history, part-critical probing into CW culture in cacademic verbiage, veering into random critical opinions on various writers that interest him (Roth, Larsen, Thomas Woolf), and no one else, and nailing them to the thread of his discourse with bent nails and limp twine. I pressed on to p.240 for reasons that seem inexplicable to me now, and will remain so.
I've never read literary theory before “The Program Era,” which I became interested in after reading Charles McGrath's article in the New York Times (nyti/PonziWorkshop) and in Louis Menand's piece in the New Yorker (bit/ProgramMenand).I got about a hundred pages in before someone else at the Mutlnomah County Library put it on hold. Then I put it on hold, and this unknown reader and I would volley it back and fourth over the space of a few months before I finally finished it. I'm imagining i [...]
Mark McGurl must be from outer space.I'll come back to that.Restart.Mark McGurl's The Program Era might be as important for what it gets right as for what it occasionally gets wrong.Restart.Mark McGurl's The Program Era is perhaps the most important book of The Program Era, an essential text in the newly energized field we might call "creative writing studies," after Graeme Harper and Jeri Kroll's Creative Writing Studies: Practice, Research, and Pedagogy (Multilingual Matters, 2007). And writte [...]
A history of creative writing programs offered by American colleges and universities since the 1940's. Sounds pretty dry, doesn't it? The Program Era turns out to be both a closely studied cultural history and a witty account of the tensions to be found in the relationships of writers and teachers. The background is set with an interesting account of Thomas Wolfe as a precursor who taught early programs. The book posits the University of Iowa as the first true university program as we know them [...]
After reading a belated review in The New York Review of Books of Mark McGurl’s The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing of 2009, I ordered the 466-page study, read it immediately, and found it fascinating and timely.McGurl, an English professor at Stamford University, focuses on the Post-World-War-II rise of “creative writing” as a serious academic subject. He chronicles favorite writers such as Raymond Carver, Flannery O’Connor and others who were trained at th [...]
An awesome book if you're already interested in the premise: exploring most of 20th century American literature through the lens of the creative writing program, and how many can be easily and beneficially understood as reactions to that program. However, it's a rough ask if you aren't, since the chapters are incredibly long—up to 70 pages in length—and constitute a free-flowing narrative on the different elements of creative writing programs and how they're instantiated in up to a dozen cas [...]
I kind of can't believe I read this whole thing. I think there's some interesting stuff in here but it's too dense for the layperson to get much out of it. Pretty much it went over my head and I'm no dummy!
The pat story we all got from our lit. survey courses (probably from the Norton anthologies) explaining the transition from the Modern to the Postmodern period had to do with the conclusion of World War II and the change in attitudes this had on the American population generally, which was captured by the literature and called postmodern. While no one is seriously arguing that the postmodern period isn't real anymore (as was still the case even ten years ago) scholars are now attending to the tr [...]
As a critic, McGurl widens (and narrows, for he is an inveterate psychologizer, a modulator) our sense of the context for fifty to a hundred American fictive texts, none of which is he trying to rank. As a scholar, he travels amid the discursive formations these widely-ranging fictions have attracted, and offers a map of the field that emboldens me to read further in it. As a theorist, his maps are lovingly dialectical, they keep synthesizing and re-emerging in their differences, in their capaci [...]
very thought-provoking. argument on postwar american lit has replaced a sense of historical textuality (if there was one, that is, which is not clear, given the postwar nature of the materials) with the aura of the "encounter with the living writer." i'm not convinced that I agree with McCurl's criteria for the "best" literary fiction, but he does account for the obsession with writerliness at the expense of reading in a convincing way. i wish he had a third thing: NOT 1) the "influence" paradig [...]
The is a brilliant book that will change the way I teach about contemporary American fiction. It is a welcome corrective to the all-too-common knee jerk condemnation of all work related to creative writing programs. This book tries to take seriously what it means when academic experience comes to dominate literary fiction. This book is authoritative and wide ranging (though the cost of that is a book that's longer than is necessary). What I liked most about it were the many moments when McGurl o [...]
I wanted this one to be better. When McGurl is actually performing readings of novels and stories, he's good. (He 'reads' some of the major 20th Century American writers, and thus their work, as products of the workshop system.) But too much of the book reads like a repurposed dissertation: Larded down with critical scaffolding that is, by turns, irrelevant, show-offy, unreadably gnarled, and repetitive. The theory makes McGurl timid; its hair-splitting teaches him that the thing to be most fear [...]
This book is far more favorable than many might be to the results of the uniform application of fairly standardized teaching methods to literature. Nonetheless, Mr. McGurl makes clear how the writing program approach has come to dominate writing, editing and general literary standards in the US.For instance, readers may find it illuminating to discover that the trinity of nostrums: 'Write what you know' ; 'Find your voice'; and 'Show don't tell' are the watchwords of writing program tutelage. Th [...]
The Ponzi WorkshopBookforumShow or TellChronicle profile (paywall)LRB ("McGurl appears to believe that ‘point of view’ was somehow invented by Henry James.")Critical Flame (not sure if this is journal or website)
This is a big and important (and, fortunately, very well written) book about the influence of creative writing instruction on postwar literary production. It's frankly a scandal that this book wasn't written long ago -- there have been histories of creative writing, like D.G. Myer's The Elephants Teach, but not as far as I know a literature-focused history that systematically studies how creative writing pedagogy shapes literature -- but we're lucky to have such a surefooted guide through this t [...]
By Éilís Ní Dhuibhne, Irish Examiner:"There's much food for thought in what McGurl has to say about literary trends. Most, interesting, though, is his sensitive exploration of the interplay between individual writers and the Creative Writing programsOpinionated and livelyHe delivers a cornucopia of exciting new ideas and insights in a work which will be indispensable reading for teachers and students of creative writing, and for anyone interested in modern fiction[A:] complex, energetic and f [...]
a great example of all that an academic book can be- funny, well-written, sophisticated and expansive in themes and subject matter. anyone who has a humanities degree from a college or university should read it. I will be interested to talk to some people who have read a lot of the scholarship on post-war american fiction and see what they think about it.
A compelling argument that places the creative writing program at the center of postwar fiction. It's a premise that makes so much sense and an argument so persuasive that in retrospect I can't believe someone hasn't carried out this analysis already. It's also extremely readable. My only major complaint is that the book doesn't need to be as long as it is.
Much more literary analysis and theory and much less history than I expected. McGurl achieves what one should in the post-po-mo domain of literary studies and does it with clarity and flair.
Stuff on Cuckoo's Nest and Ken Kesey is great. A bit too "scholarly" for my taste. But well done. Took me almost five years to read the whole thing. Not a criticism. Just the truth.
808.04207 M1489 2009
Unlimited [Biography Book] ☆ The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing - by Mark McGurl ↠ 448 Mark McGurl
Title: Unlimited [Biography Book] ☆ The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing - by Mark McGurl ↠